Re: Tools are not the Answer

I quoted Uncle Bob’s post two days back and Hillel Wayne has written a much comprehensive response to the original post. In summary, it says:

Uncle Bob gives terrible advice. Following it will make your code worse.

I see nowhere in the original article where it says the tools are bad for you. In fact, it maintains that:

I have nothing against tools like this. I’ve even contributed money to the Light Table project. I think that good software tools make it easier to write good software. However, tools are not the answer to the “Apocalypse”.

There’s a very interesting discussion on Hacker News as well and I urge you to go read it. Uncle Bob Martin himself has left a few (albeit succinct) comments. It’s very interesting to listen to all parts of the story, especially from people who have far greater experience than you.

Post a comment or leave a trackback: Trackback URL.

Leave a Reply